Latest

Home Alone Sequel Faces a Major Problem as Original Director Chris Columbus Says It Cannot Work Without Catherine O’Hara

The Home Alone sequel is finally moving forward with Macaulay Culkin expected to return as Kevin McCallister, but the announcement has already raised an uncomfortable question. Original director Chris Columbus believes another film cannot recreate what made the franchise special without Catherine O’Hara, who played Kevin’s mother in the first two movies. His comments arrived just as Disney’s new project entered early development, creating an unexpected disagreement between the filmmaker and the studio’s plans for one of its most recognisable Christmas franchises.

Home Alone sequel brings Macaulay Culkin back to Disney

Disney is developing a new Home Alone instalment through 20th Century Studios, with Culkin involved in developing the story alongside Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg. The pair will work on the screenplay and produce through their Point Grey production banner. The development was reported by Variety, which confirmed that the project remains in its early stages.

There is still very little information about the actual film. Disney has declined to comment, and no additional cast members, director or release date have been announced. Rogen and Goldberg also have another commitment to complete before they can fully concentrate on Home Alone: an original horror comedy for Universal that they intend to direct themselves.

For Culkin, this would be his first proper return to the franchise as Kevin since Home Alone 2: Lost in New York in 1992. He was only nine when the original 1990 film made him one of the most recognisable child actors in Hollywood. His performance as the resourceful youngster defending his house from two burglars became a Christmas tradition for millions of families.

The announcement also comes after Culkin gradually became more comfortable embracing his most famous character again. He has appeared in Home Alone-themed advertisements and participated in special anniversary screenings. His recent Christmas commercial for McDonald’s, released on November 17, brought Kevin back into the spotlight and helped renew interest in a possible sequel.

Chris Columbus believes Home Alone cannot work without Catherine O’Hara

The biggest complication arrived through comments from Chris Columbus, who directed both original Home Alone films. Speaking to Variety shortly before the sequel news became public, Columbus revealed that he was unaware of the project. When discussing the possibility of another instalment, he explained that Catherine O’Hara and Culkin were the emotional centre of the original films.

Columbus described O’Hara as 50% of Home Alone and explained that the relationship between Kate and Kevin gave the comedy its emotional foundation. O’Hara, who died on January 30, 2026, aged 71, played the mother desperately trying to reunite with her son after accidentally leaving him behind during the family’s Christmas vacation.

His concern is understandable. Home Alone was never remembered simply because a child outsmarted two burglars using elaborate household traps. The film worked because its comedy was balanced by a family story. Kevin initially enjoys being alone, but his excitement gradually turns into loneliness. Meanwhile, Kate’s desperate journey to get home gives the film an emotional thread that connects the ridiculous situations with something audiences genuinely care about.

Columbus also defended the original chemistry between Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern, who played Harry and Marv. He argued that later filmmakers failed to understand what made the pair so entertaining. According to him, their comic chemistry was difficult to reproduce, and replacing that combination was never going to be straightforward.

The director did leave some room for another film featuring members of the original ensemble. However, he made it clear that O’Hara’s absence changes the possibilities considerably. His position is particularly interesting because he was not attacking Culkin’s return. In fact, he praised the actor’s recent Christmas commercial and expressed an interest in working with him again, whether on a Home Alone-related project or something else.

Macaulay Culkin already has an idea for adult Kevin

Interestingly, the new film appears to have originated from an idea that Culkin himself had been discussing for some time. During his A Nostalgic Night with Macaulay Culkin tour in November 2025, the actor explained how he imagined Kevin’s life several decades after the events of the original films. Rather than bringing back the same childhood formula, he wanted to explore what happens when the former prankster becomes a parent.

His proposed story would follow an older Kevin who is either widowed or divorced and raising a child. He works extremely hard and struggles to give his son enough attention, creating tension between the two. Things take an unexpected turn when Kevin finds himself locked outside his own house, with his son refusing to let him back in and setting traps to keep him away.

The idea reverses the original premise. Kevin, who once used every trick available to defend his home from Harry and Marv, would now experience the same treatment from the next generation. The house would also represent the damaged relationship between father and son, giving the comedy a more personal conflict.

As Rolling Stone reported in its coverage of the development, Culkin had previously discussed this concept while expressing an openness to returning if the right idea came along. However, audiences should not assume that every detail from his original pitch will appear in the finished screenplay. The studio has not confirmed an official plot.

Why it matters

We think Culkin’s proposed direction is considerably more interesting than another straightforward Home Alone remake. Repeating the original formula with a different child, a different house and another pair of burglars would risk making the franchise feel like an annual exercise in nostalgia. An adult Kevin dealing with the responsibilities of parenthood offers a genuine reason to revisit the character.

There is also an opportunity to give the franchise something it has struggled to find in its later instalments: an emotional reason for existing. The original film connected with audiences because Kevin’s adventure was ultimately about family. A sequel exploring a father who has become so occupied with work that he neglects his own child could bring that theme back in a different way.

However, Columbus has raised a legitimate concern. O’Hara’s Kate was an essential part of the original relationship, and her absence cannot simply be ignored. A new film should acknowledge that history rather than pretending that the first two movies happened in isolation. Kevin’s adult life could provide an opportunity to explore what he learned from his mother and how those childhood experiences shaped his own approach to parenting.

Rogen and Goldberg are also an interesting creative combination for this project. Their previous collaborations include Superbad, Pineapple Express and This Is the End, while their recent television work includes Apple TV+’s The Studio. They understand character-driven comedy, but Home Alone requires a particular balance between physical humour, family emotion and Christmas nostalgia. Getting that balance right will be more important than making the traps bigger or the jokes louder.

For fans revisiting the franchise during the holiday season, our ranking of the best Christmas movies of all time is a reminder of just how deeply the original Home Alone films remain connected to annual Christmas viewing traditions. That legacy gives the new project an enormous advantage, but it also makes the expectations considerably harder to meet.

Home Alone sequel has no confirmed release date yet

For now, the project remains in early development at Disney’s 20th Century Studios. Culkin is involved in shaping the story, while Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg are attached to write and produce. No director, additional cast members or theatrical release date have been announced, and Columbus has not confirmed any involvement in the new film.

The immediate production hurdle is Rogen and Goldberg’s existing Universal horror-comedy commitment, which they must prepare before fully moving ahead with Home Alone. The bigger creative challenge will be finding a way to bring Kevin McCallister back without simply repeating the past. Whether Disney can deliver a sequel that honours O’Hara’s contribution while giving adult Kevin a story worth telling remains the biggest question surrounding the project.

Writer

Aditya Goel

Aditya Goel covers movies, TV shows and streaming for QuirkyByte. Currently based in London, he is also into markets, and he enjoys looking at what makes a film or series work for its audience. His all-time favourite show is White Collar, a good sign of his soft spot for clever, character-driven television. At QuirkyByte, he writes about films, TV and the streaming world.

Leave a Comment