The first full reviews for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping are here, and critics are sharply divided over the franchise’s return to Panem. Some reviewers are calling the new prequel a thrilling return to form, while others argue that the series has become too dependent on familiar characters and recycled storylines. Joseph Zada’s performance as young Haymitch Abernathy is earning considerable praise, but the film’s lengthy runtime and reliance on nostalgia have become major talking points ahead of its November 20 theatrical release.
Directed by Francis Lawrence, the sixth Hunger Games movie adapts Suzanne Collins’ 2025 novel and takes place 24 years before Katniss Everdeen enters the arena. It follows the 50th Hunger Games, also known as the Second Quarter Quell, in which the Capitol forces twice the usual number of tributes into its deadly competition. The film has opened to a broadly positive but far from unanimous response, with Rotten Tomatoes placing its critical approval rating in the mid-70s and Metacritic reporting a more cautious score of 56 out of 100.
Critics are divided over the return to Panem
The strongest positive reviews suggest that Sunrise on the Reaping recaptures the excitement and emotional intensity that made the original Hunger Games movies so successful. Time Out’s Phil de Semlyen awarded the film four out of five stars, describing it as a major improvement over 2023’s The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. His review particularly praised the younger Haymitch storyline and the movie’s ability to deepen the franchise’s established history without losing its political themes.
The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney offered another encouraging assessment, arguing that the new installment reconnects with the spirit of the earlier films. He praised director Francis Lawrence’s handling of the arena sequences and the emotional weight of Haymitch’s story. TheWrap’s William Bibbiani was similarly enthusiastic, suggesting that the movie’s final act helps distinguish it from the previous prequel.
However, the negative reviews have been unusually harsh. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw gave Sunrise on the Reaping just one star, calling it an unnecessary continuation of an exhausted franchise. The New York Times critic Brandon Yu also criticized the film’s storytelling, arguing that its extensive narrative leaves surprisingly little room for meaningful dramatic development.
That contrast explains the movie’s divided critical reception. For some reviewers, another journey into the Hunger Games arena remains exciting because Collins’ dystopian world continues to offer compelling stories about oppression and resistance. For others, the familiar structure has become a limitation, particularly when audiences already know the eventual fates of several important characters.
Joseph Zada’s young Haymitch earns major praise
One of the clearest points of agreement among the more favorable reviews is Joseph Zada’s performance as Haymitch Abernathy. Woody Harrelson originally portrayed the character as Katniss and Peeta’s cynical, frequently intoxicated mentor, but Sunrise on the Reaping introduces audiences to the teenager he was before becoming a victor. Zada must carry a movie whose central character is already well known, while making his younger personality feel believable on its own terms.
Rooney praised Zada’s emotional vulnerability and rebellious energy, arguing that Haymitch receives a more engaging origin story than the younger Coriolanus Snow did in The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Time Out also singled out the Australian actor as a convincing lead, suggesting that his performance helps compensate for the absence of Jennifer Lawrence as the franchise’s central protagonist. The New York Post’s Johnny Oleksinski likewise identified Zada as another promising newcomer introduced through the series.
Still, the praise has not been universal. The Daily Beast’s Nick Schager criticized the performance, finding that Zada lacked the unpredictable charisma associated with Harrelson’s older portrayal. The disagreement reflects a larger debate about whether the movie successfully transforms an established supporting character into a compelling lead.
The massive supporting cast attracts attention
Sunrise on the Reaping also features one of the franchise’s most recognizable ensembles. Ralph Fiennes portrays President Coriolanus Snow, taking over the role previously played by Donald Sutherland, while Jesse Plemons appears as a younger Plutarch Heavensbee. Kieran Culkin plays Caesar Flickerman, Elle Fanning portrays Effie Trinket, and Glenn Close joins the story as the extravagant Capitol escort Drusilla Sickle.
Several reviewers have praised how these performers bring familiar characters into an earlier period of Panem’s history. Time Out highlighted Culkin’s casting as Caesar Flickerman and Close’s deliberately exaggerated performance as Drusilla. Empire’s Olly Richards also singled out Close as one of the supporting cast’s most memorable performers, even while expressing reservations about the broader movie.
Other critics believe that the number of recognizable characters works against the story. Screen Rant’s Alex Harrison argued that the film’s entertainment value survives despite its heavy reliance on nostalgia, while other reviews questioned whether the returning character connections add enough substance. The resulting debate concerns one of the biggest challenges facing any prequel: balancing its own dramatic identity with the audience’s attachment to an existing franchise.
The brutal action and lengthy runtime spark debate
The new movie’s arena sequences have also received considerable attention, particularly for their violence and visual presentation. Rooney described the survival action as especially intense, while several other critics have suggested that Sunrise on the Reaping contains some of the franchise’s harshest deaths. The larger tribute pool also gives the Second Quarter Quell a different scale from the competitions depicted in previous films.
Director Francis Lawrence returns after directing Catching Fire, both Mockingjay installments and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Several positive reviews credit him with creating a visually distinctive version of Panem, with unusual colors, elaborate Capitol designs and a different atmosphere inside the arena. However, critics have also raised concerns about artificial-looking visual effects and whether the spectacle remains as unsettling as it once was.
At two hours and 38 minutes, the film is another lengthy entry in the series. Even positive reviewers, including Time Out, have suggested that the movie could have benefited from tighter editing, particularly during its later sections. Critics at Bleeding Cool and The Daily Beast have similarly questioned whether the adaptation gives its extensive source material enough space to develop naturally.
The first reviews reveal a familiar Hunger Games divide
The mixed reception creates an interesting situation for a franchise that has already successfully expanded beyond Katniss Everdeen’s original story. Sunrise on the Reaping arrives with an established fan audience, a bestselling source novel and an ensemble filled with recognizable performers. Yet the initial reviews suggest that familiarity with Panem can be either a major advantage or a significant drawback, depending on what viewers want from another prequel.
Rotten Tomatoes’ early review roundup indicates that several critics consider the movie a welcome return to the original films’ themes, while others regard it as a repetition of ideas the series has already explored. A mid-70s approval rating means most participating critics have offered broadly favorable verdicts, rather than an evenly divided positive-negative split. Metacritic’s lower average reflects the reservations expressed even in some of those favorable reviews, particularly about pacing and familiar storytelling.
The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens in US and UK theaters on November 20, 2026, with preview screenings taking place ahead of the official release. Its critical reception is now established, but the wider audience response will provide another measure of how successfully Haymitch’s story connects with viewers. Are you more excited to see Joseph Zada’s version of Haymitch, or do the reviews suggesting that the franchise is repeating itself make you hesitant about another Hunger Games prequel?



